What Microsoft 365 evidence should you collect for cyber insurance?

Start with your insurer’s current questionnaire. Ask your broker which users, systems, and sign-in methods each question covers and what evidence they accept. A Microsoft 365 review can help you answer questions about your cloud tenant. Check other systems separately when the question also covers VPNs, servers, or third-party applications.

Document where MFA is enforced

Collect dated screenshots or exports from the Microsoft Entra admin center. If you use Conditional Access, record the policies that are on, the users and applications they cover, any conditions or exclusions, and the grant controls that require MFA or a particular authentication strength. Check whether a policy allows a compliant device as an alternative to MFA. Report-only policies show how a rule would apply. If you use Security Defaults, capture the enabled setting. It requires administrators to use MFA and prompts other users when Microsoft determines it is necessary.

Pair the configuration with recent sign-in examples for a staff account and an administrator using the relevant applications. In Entra sign-in logs, review both the policy result and Authentication Details. An existing MFA claim can satisfy a requirement without a fresh prompt. Where available, use the registration report to identify who has set up an MFA method. Use the policy settings and sampled events to show when MFA is required and how it was satisfied.

List exceptions and who reviews them

Compare the accounts in scope with the users and groups included in the policies. Check excluded groups, guest access if covered by the questionnaire, and privileged accounts. For each exception, record the account or group, what it can access, the reason, the safeguard in place, and who will review it by what date.

If emergency admin accounts are excluded from a Conditional Access policy, document their separate phishing-resistant sign-in method, monitoring, and last access test. If a gap remains, describe which accounts or applications it affects and give the planned fix date.

Record the results of a backup restore

List the workloads your backup covers, such as Exchange Online, SharePoint, or OneDrive. Capture the backup schedule, retention period, who can manage backups, and any separate or protected copy relevant to the question. Then run an authorized restore to a designated test location for a representative mailbox item or SharePoint file.

Keep the job record and the date, workload, backup timestamp, time to restore, and person who verified the result. Record whether the restored data opened and matched what you expected. Compare the result with your recovery targets for that workload and state which workloads remain untested.

Package the evidence for renewal

Keep one row per question with the answer, systems covered, evidence date, link to the supporting record, and any exceptions or open work. Keep full records in a restricted location and send only the evidence requested through the broker’s approved channel. Redact unrelated names, email addresses, and network details as appropriate.

Your IT provider can gather the records. Our Small Business Security Assessment can review the evidence within the agreed scope and help prioritize the gaps. Ask your broker or insurer to confirm what they require for your policy.

Sources

Tell us what you need to prove.

Send a short brief. We’ll confirm the fit, what we need to see, and how we’d scope the work.

Scope a project